COVID-19 Update: We are here for you, our clients. Learn more
Monday April 6, 2020

Ontario Court of Appeal Finds Ways to Hear Appeals During COVID-19

Authored by: Terrance G. Sheppard Posted in: COVID-19 Family Law

Unlike Nova Scotia, the Ontario Court of Appeal is allowing parties who had scheduled appeals to request their appeal be heard in writing. Information can be found here. In contrast, the Nova Scotia Court of Appeal has adjourned or postponed all hearings that were scheduled for May/June with no option to proceed in writing. Information can be found here.

In Carleton Condominium Corporation No. 476 v. Wong, 2020 ONCA 244 (“Carleton Condominium”), the Ontario Court of Appeal conducted a teleconference on April 2, 2020 to rule on whether the appeal should postpone until the fall or continue, either based on the written material alone, with a full oral hearing by teleconference, or some other means.

The Ontario Court of Appeal held, “It is in the interests of justice to have the appeal proceed in writing based on the materials filed. The parties will have an opportunity to respond, by teleconference, to any questions the panel may have, on the date set for the appeal, April 9, 2020.”1

The Court decided the appeal could fairly proceed in writing since one of the parties was a lawyer and the written materials filed by both parties were professionally prepared.2 The issues were also capable of being decided in writing, the Court of Appeal held.3

The Court stated that even if the appellant had a preference to present his arguments during an in-court oral hearing, this was not in the interests of justice.4 Specifically, delaying the appeal would be prejudicial to these parties and the overall court system. At paragraph 7, the Court noted:

[7] Moreover, it is not in the interests of justice to overburden the court by adjourning matters that can be dealt with fairly, as scheduled. The backlog that will be created by cases that must be adjourned to protect the public and ensure fair hearings will be imposing and it should not be unnecessarily aggravated.

The court also held that they would not have a full, oral hearing by telephone conference, but rather, the parties would only be given the opportunity to respond to any questions by the panel of judges hearing the appeal. The court held that completing the entire oral hearing by teleconference would lead to a litigation advantage for one party, as the other did not have the knowledge or infrastructure to proceed given the COVID-19 pandemic.5

To discuss your unique situation amidst COVID-19, talk to Terrance G. Sheppard or a member of our Family Law team. Request your free 30-minute consultation via phone or virtual meeting platform (Skype, Zoom, FaceTime, etc.). 

This is legal information and is not intended to be legal advice.


1 Carleton Condominium Corporation No. 476 v Wong, 2020 ONCA 244 at para 2.

2 Carleton Condominium Corporation No. 476 v Wong, 2020 ONCA 244 at para 3.

3 Carleton Condominium Corporation No. 476 v Wong, 2020 ONCA 244 at para 3.

4 Carleton Condominium Corporation No. 476 v Wong, 2020 ONCA 244 at para 5.

5 Carleton Condominium Corporation No. 476 v Wong, 2020 ONCA 244 at para 8.

Share This Post:

Ask a question about this post.

Any Questions

Recent Blog Posts

Blog Post | Friday September 4, 2020

Dealing with bone and soft-tissue injuries

Authored by: Shafic A. Khouri Authored by: David S.R. Parker Posted in: Personal Injury

What is an orthopaedic injury?
What causes orthopaedic injuries?
Are there legal differences between soft-tissue injuries and fractures?

Read full article
Blog Post | Monday August 17, 2020

Canada Expands Definition of “Parent” under the Citizenship Act

Authored by: Terrance G. Sheppard Authored by: Scott McGirr Posted in: Family Law Immigration

On July 9th, the Minister of Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship, Marco E. L. Mendicino, announced a change in the interpretation of "parent" under the Citizenship Act.

Read full article
Blog Post | Friday July 17, 2020

Return to treatment series: Get your healthcare even during the COVID-19 pandemic

Authored by: Shafic A. Khouri Authored by: David S.R. Parker Posted in: COVID-19 Personal Injury

Recently, governments have started to ease restrictions and, as a result, healthcare providers have started opening their doors for in-person treatments. We asked chiropractor Dr. Liam Ryan a few questions about the clinic Nova Physiotherapy and how it is operating during this time.

Read full article
Blog Post | Tuesday July 7, 2020

Don’t let COVID-19 stop you from getting the healthcare treatment you need

Authored by: Shafic A. Khouri Authored by: David S.R. Parker Posted in: COVID-19 Personal Injury

The COVID-19 pandemic has disrupted many of the activities and routines in people’s daily lives. We asked chiropractor Kate MacAdam at Dr. MacAdam and Associates a few questions about her clinic and how it is operating during this time.

Read full article